Pressing play loads Spotify’s player, which may set cookies. Listen on Spotify
Titanium is as strong as many steels at a little over half the weight, shrugs off salt water, and bone will actually bond to it. So why do machinists make a face when you ask for it? In episode 3 of Grain Boundary, Sam and Dan cover Grade 2, Grade 5 and Grade 23, why titanium is “hot, springy and sticky” in the machine, and the most important question to ask before ordering a titanium part.
In this episode
- 00:51 Strength for its weight, corrosion resistance, and why bone bonds to it
- 02:03 The grade map: commercially pure Grades 1–4, Grade 5 and Grade 23
- 03:56 Why titanium is hard to machine: hot, springy and sticky
- 05:21 Shop safety: titanium chips and fire
- 05:53 Why titanium parts cost more
- 06:23 The SR-71 Blackbird and dye-free colored anodizing
- 07:23 Welding titanium
- 07:48 How to choose: do you really need titanium?
Quick reference
| Grade | Type | Key feature | Typical uses |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grade 1–4 | Commercially pure | Grade 1 is softest and most formable; strength rises up to Grade 4 | Corrosion-resistant parts that don’t carry big loads |
| Grade 2 | Commercially pure | About as strong as mild steel; forms and welds well | Chemical plants, heat exchangers, marine parts |
| Grade 5 (Ti-6Al-4V) | Alloy: 6% aluminum, 4% vanadium | More than twice as strong as Grade 2; about 330 Brinell; roughly half of all titanium used | Aircraft brackets, engine parts, fasteners, race parts |
| Grade 23 (6-4 ELI) | Alloy, extra-low impurities | Tougher and more forgiving version of Grade 5 | Medical implants |
Titanium weighs a little over half as much as steel. For comparison, mild steel is about 120 Brinell and 7075-T6 aluminum about 150. Before choosing titanium, check whether 7075 aluminum or 17-4 stainless would do the job.
Transcript
00:00 Sam: Hey, welcome back to Grain Boundary, the show about what things are actually made of. I’m Sam.
00:05 Dan: And I’m Dan. And so far we’ve done aluminum, and we’ve done stainless steel.
00:09 Sam: And today we’re doing the one that sounds like it belongs in a superhero movie.
00:14 Dan: Titanium.
00:16 Sam: Titanium! Even the name is dramatic.
00:19 Dan: It’s literally named after the Titans from Greek mythology. Somebody back in the seventeen-nineties decided this metal needed a cool name, and they were right.
00:28 Sam: And it’s everywhere now, right? Watches, golf clubs, bike frames…
00:33 Dan: You’ll find it in hip implants and dental implants, in jet engines and landing gear, and even in some phones and laptops. It went from exotic to, honestly, kind of normal.
00:43 Sam: But it’s still expensive, and machinists still make a face when you say it.
00:46 Dan: They do. And by the end of this episode, you’ll know exactly why.
00:51 Sam: Okay, so start with the basics. What makes titanium special?
00:55 Dan: Three things. First, strength for its weight. The strong titanium alloys are about as strong as a lot of steels, at a little over half the weight.
01:04 Sam: So it sits between aluminum and steel.
01:07 Dan: Right. Heavier than aluminum, lighter than steel, but stronger than almost any aluminum. Second, corrosion. Titanium shrugs off salt water and a lot of chemicals better than even three-sixteen stainless.
01:19 Sam: Let me guess. Oxide layer.
01:22 Dan: Oxide layer! Third episode in a row. Titanium grows a thin, tough oxide skin, just like aluminum and stainless. And titanium’s is one of the toughest of them all.
01:32 Sam: We should make that a drinking game.
01:34 Dan: Please don’t.
01:37 Sam: And the third thing?
01:39 Dan: The third thing is the wild one. Your body likes it. Titanium is so well tolerated that bone will actually grow right up against it and bond to it. That’s why it’s the go-to metal for dental implants and joint replacements.
01:51 Sam: Bone bonds to it? That’s amazing.
01:54 Dan: It really is. It was discovered more or less by accident, by a researcher in the nineteen-fifties who couldn’t get his titanium devices back out of the bone.
02:03 Sam: Okay, give us the map. Like we did with aluminum and stainless.
02:07 Dan: So titanium is simpler than aluminum. There are two big groups. First, commercially pure titanium, which comes in Grades one through four. Grade one is the softest and most formable, and as you go up to Grade four, it gets stronger.
02:22 Sam: And the second group?
02:25 Dan: The alloys. And there’s one alloy that basically runs the show. Grade five. Also called six-four, because it’s titanium with six percent aluminum and four percent vanadium.
02:35 Sam: Six-four. I’ve seen that on bike frames.
02:38 Dan: You see it everywhere. Grade five is roughly half of all the titanium used in the world. Aircraft brackets, engine parts, fasteners, implants, race car parts.
02:49 Sam: So the two you’ll hear about most in a machine shop are…
02:52 Dan: Grade two and Grade five. Grade two is the commercially pure workhorse. It’s great for corrosion, it forms and welds nicely, and you see it in chemical plants, heat exchangers, marine parts. Grade five is the strength grade. Way stronger than Grade two.
03:07 Sam: Give me a number. You know I like the numbers.
03:09 Dan: Okay. Strength-wise, Grade two is roughly as strong as plain mild steel. Grade five is more than twice that.
03:17 Sam: At a little over half the weight.
03:19 Dan: At a little over half the weight. And on our Brinell scale, where mild steel, remember, was around one-twenty…
03:26 Sam: One twenty. Burned into my brain.
03:29 Dan: Grade five is up around three hundred thirty. That’s way past even seventy seventy-five, our strongest aluminum from episode one, which was about one-fifty.
03:38 Sam: Okay, and then there’s that implant version, right? I’ve seen “ELI” somewhere.
03:43 Dan: Yes! Grade twenty-three. It’s six-four with extra-low impurities. ELI stands for extra low interstitial. It’s a bit tougher and more forgiving, so it’s the preferred version for medical implants.
03:56 Sam: Okay. Now the part everyone’s waiting for. Why do machinists make that face?
04:01 Dan: So, remember stainless? We said it fights back.
04:04 Sam: Work hardening, and the heat stays at the tool.
04:07 Dan: Titanium is that, but more. Problem one is heat. Titanium is even worse at conducting heat than stainless. Something like twenty times worse than aluminum. So all the heat from cutting piles up right on the cutting edge.
04:21 Sam: Which cooks the tool.
04:23 Dan: Which cooks the tool. Problem two, titanium is springy. It’s about half as stiff as steel. So when you cut it, it pushes back and flexes away from the tool. If you’ve got a thin wall or a long, skinny part, it can start vibrating. Machinists call it chatter.
04:38 Sam: And that leaves a bad finish?
04:40 Dan: Bad finish, bad tolerances, broken tools. And problem three, hot titanium is chemically really reactive. It wants to stick to the cutting tool and weld itself onto the edge.
04:51 Sam: So it’s hot, it’s springy, and it’s sticky.
04:55 Dan: That’s titanium machining in five words.
04:58 Sam: So how do you actually cut it?
05:00 Dan: A lot of the same rules as stainless, turned up. Run slower speeds than you would in steel. Keep the feed going so you’re always cutting, never rubbing. Use sharp tools, rigid setups, and a lot of coolant, ideally high-pressure coolant blasting right at the edge.
05:14 Sam: Don’t be shy.
05:16 Dan: Don’t be shy! Same rule. The worst thing you can do with titanium is hesitate.
05:21 Sam: There’s also a safety thing with titanium chips, right?
05:24 Dan: Yeah, and it surprises people. Big titanium chips are fine. But very fine chips, shavings and dust can actually catch fire. And a titanium fire is no joke. It burns extremely hot, and water can make it worse.
05:37 Sam: Wow.
05:38 Dan: So good shops keep titanium chips separate, keep them clean, and keep a special Class D fire extinguisher nearby, the kind made for metal fires.
05:47 Sam: That’s a little terrifying.
05:49 Dan: It’s very manageable when you respect it. But you have to respect it.
05:53 Sam: Okay, money. Why does a titanium part cost so much more?
05:57 Dan: Two reasons. First, the raw material. Titanium is actually really common in the earth’s crust. But getting pure metal out of the ore is slow and takes a huge amount of energy. So the bar stock alone can cost many times more than aluminum.
06:12 Sam: And second?
06:14 Dan: Second is everything we just talked about. Slower cutting, more tool wear, more care. So you’re paying more for the metal and more for the machine time.
06:23 Sam: Okay, a couple of quick stories, because I know you have them.
06:26 Dan: I always have them. My favorite is the SR-71 Blackbird. That spy plane was made mostly of titanium, because at its speeds, the skin got so hot that aluminum would have gone soft.
06:38 Sam: Oh right, titanium keeps its strength at higher temperatures.
06:41 Dan: Much better than aluminum, yeah. And the crazy part? During the Cold War, a lot of the titanium for that plane was bought from the Soviet Union, through middlemen. They basically built a spy plane out of their rival’s metal.
06:53 Sam: That is incredible.
06:55 Dan: And one more fun one. Titanium can be anodized into colors without any dye at all.
07:01 Sam: Wait, how?
07:03 Dan: It’s that oxide layer again. You grow it to a precise thickness, and light reflecting off it creates the color, kind of like a soap bubble or an oil slick. Blue, gold, purple. Change the voltage, change the thickness, change the color.
07:16 Sam: Okay, that’s going in the bar facts collection, next to the soda can.
07:20 Dan: Good company.
07:23 Sam: And welding? Can you weld it?
07:25 Dan: You can, but you have to be really careful. Hot titanium grabs oxygen and nitrogen from the air, and that makes the weld brittle. So welders flood the whole area with argon gas, even the back side. And the color of the weld tells you how you did. Shiny silver or light straw is good. Blue or gray means it got contaminated.
07:43 Sam: The metal literally tells on you.
07:45 Dan: It really does.
07:48 Sam: Okay, let’s land the plane. Say I’m a customer and I’m thinking about titanium. How do I decide?
07:54 Dan: First question, honestly: do you really need titanium? Because a lot of the time, something cheaper does the job.
08:01 Sam: Like what?
08:03 Dan: If you just need light and strong, seventy seventy-five aluminum might do it, at a fraction of the cost. If you need strong and corrosion resistant, seventeen-four stainless might do it. A good shop will ask you that.
08:15 Sam: So when is titanium the right answer?
08:18 Dan: When you need a few of those things at the same time. Strength for the weight, plus corrosion resistance, plus maybe heat, or maybe it’s going in the human body. That’s where nothing else really competes.
08:29 Sam: And then Grade two or Grade five?
08:31 Dan: If corrosion and forming matter most, and the part doesn’t carry big loads, Grade two. If strength matters, Grade five. And for implants, Grade twenty-three.
08:42 Sam: Okay, quick recap. Titanium is strong like steel at a little over half the weight. It resists corrosion better than stainless, and bone bonds to it. Grade two is the pure, corrosion-resistant workhorse. Grade five, six-four, is the strength grade and the most common alloy. It’s hard to machine because it’s hot, springy and sticky. Fine chips can burn, so respect them. And it costs more, both for the metal and the machine time.
09:08 Dan: And last time it was “always check the grade.”
09:10 Sam: So this time?
09:13 Dan: Always ask, do I really need titanium?
09:15 Sam: And if you do, it’s worth every penny. That’s it for this episode of Grain Boundary. Thanks for listening, and we’ll see you next time.
09:23 Dan: Take care, everyone.